Asmad Surma vs Kajal – Which Is Better for Eyes?

When it comes to eye makeup and eye care, two popular choices are Asmad Surma and Kajal. Both give a beautiful look to the eyes, but they are not the same. Their ingredients, benefits, and effects on eye health are very different. If you want to know which one is better for your eyes, here’s a simple guide.

What Is Asmad Surma?

Asmad Surma is a traditional, natural kohl made from Ithmid / Ismid / Athmad stone. It is a grey-black mineral powder known for its cooling, cleansing, and protective benefits.
People have used Asmad Surma for centuries, especially in Arabia and South Asia.

Key Features of Asmad Surma

• Made from natural Ithmid stone

• Helps strengthen eyesight

• Protects eyes from dust and pollutants

• Keeps eyes cool and relaxed

• Chemical-free and safe for regular use

What Is Kajal?

Kajal is a cosmetic eyeliner commonly used for beauty purposes. Most commercial kajals are made with:

• Wax

• Oils

• Soot

• Cosmetic pigments

Although it looks dark and gives a bold eye effect, it often contains chemicals that may irritate sensitive eyes.

Key Features of Kajal

• Mainly for cosmetic use

• Gives a smooth, bold, dark look

• May contain chemicals or preservatives

• Can smudge easily

• Not always ideal for sensitive eyes

Asmad Surma vs Kajal – Main Differences

1. Purpose

• Asmad Surma: Eye health + beauty

• Kajal: Beauty only

2. Ingredients

• Asmad Surma: Pure Ithmid stone powder

• Kajal: Cosmetic waxes, soot, pigments, and sometimes chemicals

3. Eye Health Benefits

• Asmad Surma:

  • Improves eyesight

  • Cleanses eyes

  • Helps reduce redness or irritation

  • Protects from dust

• Kajal:

  • No proven eye health benefits

  • Sometimes causes itching or watering

4. Safety

• Asmad Surma: Natural, safe, fragrance-free

• Kajal: Depends on brand; not all formulas are safe

What Do Hadith Say About Surma?

There are narrations where Ithmid Surma is encouraged for eye health:

Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) said:
“The best of your kohl is Ithmid, for it clears the eyesight and makes the eyelashes grow.”
(Reported in An-Nasa’i)

This shows that Asmad/Ithmid Surma has traditional, historical, and health-supported importance.

Kajal, on the other hand, is not mentioned in hadith and is mainly a cosmetic innovation.

Which Is Better for Eyes?

 

If you want something safe, natural, and beneficial, then Asmad Surma is clearly better than kajal. It supports eye health, is chemical-free, and has been used for centuries.
Kajal is good for makeup looks, but when it comes to eye care, Asmad Surma is the better choice.

Buy our 100% Natural Al Asmad Surma to keep your eyes healthy, cool, and protected every day.
For orders, WhatsApp us at 0313-1774438 or visit ShesCollection.pk.